Skip to main content

Blog entry by Derek Werfel

You are standing in the grocery store spice aisle, staring at two jars of saffron. One costs ten dollars, the other costs thirty. You wonder if the cheap one is real or if you are being tricked. Saffron is the most faked spice in the pantry, and the reason is simple: it costs more per gram than silver. So how do you tell real from fake without a lab?

Drop a single thread in warm water. Real saffron releases its color slowly, turning the water a golden orange over a few minutes. Dyed imitations stain the water instantly, often turning it bright yellow or red. The shape matters too. A real stigma flares at one end like a trumpet, and it never looks uniform. Fake threads are often uniform, cut from something like corn silk or colored plastic. You can also rub a thread between your fingers. Real saffron feels dry and brittle, not waxy or greasy.

But there is more to saffron than avoiding a bad purchase. The research interest in this spice centers on two compounds, crocin and safranal. Crocin is what gives saffron its color, and safranal gives it that distinctive smell. These two compounds are why saffron shows up in supplements, usually at a much smaller dose than a recipe uses. A pinch in a paella might give you a few milligrams, but a supplement capsule might contain a concentrated extract.

The question many people ask is whether saffron can help with memory. Some small studies suggest it might, particularly in older adults. The idea is that crocin and safranal have antioxidant properties that protect brain cells from damage over time. One study followed people with mild memory complaints and found that those taking a saffron supplement performed slightly better on memory tests than those taking a placebo. But the effects were modest, and the studies were short, usually lasting a few months. No one knows yet what happens after years of use.

Saffron is not a miracle cure. It does not reverse dementia or Alzheimer's disease. But for someone who feels their memory is not as sharp as it was at forty, a daily supplement might offer a small boost. The doses used in studies are much smaller than what you would cook with. A typical supplement gives you thirty milligrams of extract, while a recipe might call for a pinch that weighs about the same. The difference is that the supplement is standardized to contain a certain percentage of crocin and safranal, so the dose is consistent.

If you buy saffron, stick with whole threads from a reputable seller. Avoid ground saffron, because it is easier to mix with fillers. Check the origin. Good saffron comes from Iran, Spain, or Kashmir. And do the water test when you get home. If the water turns yellow before the threads have time to soften, you got sold something else.

More notes on this topic are at this journal.