Skip to main content

Blog entry by Tom Doll

Most people think a phone's radio-frequency limit is a safety guard against cancer. It is not exactly that. The limit is a technical rule about heating. It says a phone cannot put more than 1.6 watts of radio energy into each kilogram of your head tissue, averaged over any one gram. That number, called the specific absorption rate or SAR, was set by the Federal Communications Commission in August 1996. It has not changed since.

The rule was based on the only clear danger that scientists agreed on back then. That danger is heat. If radio energy heats your tissue too much, it can burn you. So the limit was set far below the level that causes any measurable heating. It is a thermal standard, not a standard for other possible health effects.

Other countries use a different approach. The International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection, or ICNIRP, sets guidelines that many nations follow. Its limit for the head is 2 watts per kilogram, but it averages that over ten grams of tissue, not one. That makes the two numbers hard to compare directly. Averaging over a larger mass smooths out hot spots. So the ICNIRP rule is not stricter or looser in a simple way; it is a different way of measuring.

The FCC reviewed its limits in 2019 and decided to keep them. Some groups and individuals thought the limits should be tighter, especially for children, who might be more vulnerable. They sued the FCC. In 2021 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit gave a mixed ruling. It agreed with the FCC that there was not enough evidence to say radio-frequency energy causes cancer. But it said the FCC had not explained its reasoning well enough on other points, such as what the limits should be for children and how the agency evaluates long-term low-level exposure. The court sent those questions back to the FCC for a better explanation. It did not force a change in the limits. So the 1996 numbers are still the law.

If you want to know how much radio energy a specific phone puts out, you can look up its FCC ID. The FCC keeps the SAR test results for every phone sold in the United States. Those records show that the phone met the 1996 limit when it was tested. They do not settle the larger health argument. That argument continues in scientific journals and before the agency.

class=

The question of whether long-term low-level exposure matters is not answered by the current limit. The FCC is still working through the issues the court sent back. No one knows when it will finish. If you are worried about radio-frequency exposure and your health, that is a question for your doctor and for the scientific literature. If you want to know what the law requires, the law still says 1.6 watts per kilogram over one gram of tissue. That number has not budged since Bill Clinton was president.

For more on this, see why the FCC limits date from 1996.